Letter: Society’s relations with innovation need a rethink

[ad_1]

Anjana Ahuja is right (Opinion, March 29). Profit has consistently been put before the health and wellbeing of people in terms of policy and regulation. In addition to the junk food, cigarettes and alcohol mentioned in the article, social media, gambling, opioids and the new disposable vapes targeted at children, all have a business model deliberately designed to addict their customers.

The problem is rooted in three entrenched ideologies, which need confronting.

The first ideology is neoliberal capitalism, which prioritises a right to make money over human rights, environmental sustainability and the good of society as a whole. Damage to individuals and society is actively incentivised by a system that allows companies to take the money and leave the externalities for individuals and governments to deal with.

The second is innovation as an ideology. Innovation is now not a simple description — “the introduction of new things, ideas, or ways of doing something” (Oxford English Dictionary). It is focused on science and technology-driven products, which it enshrines as intrinsically “a good thing”. Innovation as ideology believes that nothing should get in its way and anyone suggesting otherwise is anti-business and anti-progress.

The third ideology is the belief that regulation stifles innovation. Bad regulation stifles innovation. Good regulation, as the article proposes, shepherds those things, ideas and ways of doing something to inspire and motivate economic, social and environmental benefit and prevent or mitigate their harms.

It is useful to remember that these ideologies are not laws of nature, they are themselves just a collection of ideas that seemed like a sensible idea at the time. The good news is that there are plenty of new ideas for how, let’s call it, a “pro-society” approach to innovation, investment and regulation can be achieved. Now seems like a good time to start taking those ideas very seriously.

Hilary Sutcliffe and Joe Woof
SocietyInside, London SE21, UK

[ad_2]

Source link